There is no such thing as an Ir Hanidachas -- Wayward City -- If WE care enough
This past Shabbos we encountered the very difficult topic of עיר הנדחת (Ir Hanidachas), a wayward city of idolaters. The entire city and its inhabitants and wealth are to be destroyed and burnt – a terrible result. Some of our sages say that “there never was, nor will there ever be, an עיר הנדחת , and it appears in the Torah only for some lessons that we can learn” (Sanhedrin 71a). I have heard Rabbi Yissochor Frand שליט"א say on several occasions that when he was growing up in Seattle, they considered the Jewish community in Portland, Oregon to be a virtual עיר הנדחת . The community seemed so irredeemably lost to Torah-true Judaism that there was no hope that anything positive would come from it. Surely that was meant hyperbolically; it has been proven quite wrong, as a wonderful community has developed since the days when we had the privilege of planting some seeds. But living now as the only Shomer Shabbos family in Lavon...